I continue to maintain that John Winchester is hot like woah, and I hope that his sons will march into Hell to free him, because that would be the best EVER, and he is the badassest and the hottest, and LOVE.

New tag line after watching last night's Daily Show.

New tag line after watching last night's Daily Show.

I almost hurt myself laughing when I saw that. SC is such a big old geek it wouldn't surprise me if he was a HEROES fan.

Hee!

Note to self: catch 8pm reshowing of TDS. (which I typed TFDS, which works too)

I've decided that Niki/Jessica's power includes splitting into 2 bodies. We'll have a chick fight wrestling match at some point.

I have to admit, the first several episodes had me going "...okay..." rather than flailing wildly.

Yeah, me too. And "Home" didn't ping me on a first watch nearly as much as it does now, on rewatch. I watched the entire first season in one weekend (thanks, amyth!) and while I really enjoyed it, and loved a bunch of the episodes, I don't think the flail actually set in for me until sometime during the second season. Something about needing more time with the characters to let them settle in my head, maybe. But I'm rewatching season 1 with a friend now and there is definitely flail.

I'd say my essential SPN eps are:

"Pilot"
"Phantom Traveler" (okay, it's just a one-off, but it's HYSTERICAL)
"Home"
"Scarecrow"
"Faith"
"The Benders" (for Sheriff Kathleen!)
"Hell House"
"Something Wicked" (OMG tiny!Sam and tiny!Dean!)
"Dead Man's Blood" through "In My Time of Dying"
"Bloodlust"
"Children Shouldn't Play With Dead Things"
"Hunted"
"Night Shifter"

Eh, I don't know. I enjoy the show, but without the flailing. It's fun show, with solid writing, good acting, and attractive leads, but I've watched the show mostly in order (I think I missed "Bugs" and "Skin" from S1) and when I got to the phone scene in "Home", I sort of... laughed at the emotional string-pulling and rolled my eyes a little bit, and that's been my main response since whenever they bring out the emo porn. I like it better when the boys are snarky and are shooting stuff. Plus, I love being spooked (but hate the gore of most mainstream horror flicks) so I dig the MotW most of the time, when it's not, you know, racist ghost truck.

I think the whole family thing is a particular button that needs to be pushed in order to tip people over to flaily territory, and I just don't have it. Plus, the boys are very pretty and I can see they're objectively hot, but I'm not... attracted to either of them, which makes me a vanishing minority. Their antics remind me of my little brothers too much. Well, without the demon-possession and rock-salt shooting and being wanted by the police thing. I mostly want to ruffle their hair and thwap them on the side of their heads when they're being stupid.

I think all of my flailing is currently being used up on SGA, though now that there are no more new eps of that for ages and ages, maybe I'll have spare flail.

Are we watching the Atlantis pilot too?

I really think we should.

I think all of my flailing is currently being used up on SGA

I must have more flail than you do.

SC is such a big old geek it wouldn\'t surprise me if he was a HEROES fan.

JS, not SC.