For high conflict I'd say go with what erika suggested.
Connor ,'Not Fade Away'
The Great Write Way
A place for Buffistas to discuss, beta and otherwise deal and dish on their non-fan fiction projects.
Hmm. How about a variation of #5? As far as Lucy knows, she's not discovered, but one of the cousins catches her but doesn't interrupt, instead going to the others and telling them what she's seen and heard. That way, Lucy will be steeling herself for how to announce the engagement, only to be bushwhacked by the post-ball confrontation.
I agree with Anne.
Anne's suggestion does sound as though it has potential.
Anne is wise.
I have to say that I hate characters being humiliated for any reason. I'd suggest that no one find them
Well, the humiliation would largely be in Lucy's mind--in the eyes of all of the potential witnesses except Portia, her actions really aren't a problem as long as she and James intend to get married.
As far as Lucy knows, she's not discovered, but one of the cousins catches her but doesn't interrupt, instead going to the others and telling them what she's seen and heard.
I'd have to rework some of the logistics--maybe lose the heavy, creaky door, for example--but this has potential. The interpersonal dynamics among the cousins are such that any one of them who saw her would probably confront her first rather than telling the others, but I do like the idea. Especially if it's Julius.
Julius, though, might confront him with it, rather than her.
Hmm. I could probably work the logistics such that he wouldn't have the chance to confront James before the end of the evening, but could easily confront Lucy, because as family members they're staying at the same place.
If Lucy suffers a major embarassment, even if it's all in her head, it'll color her developing relationship with James - don't know what you've got planned, but is that okay? It's also a question of how major an event you want this to be. Will it throw things off kilter?
Just some thoughts. I think you've gotten some pretty good advice already.
Well, they need some roadblocks--they're really quite well-matched, if I do say so myself, and if they realize it too soon, it'll throw the pacing of the story off, since I'm bucking recent romance tradition by not throwing some random enemy into the last forty pages to kidnap Lucy so he can murder James or something lame like that.