I am just amused that her characters seem to be well versed in obscure wildlife articles, given that they keep quoting them verbatim.
Obscure wildlife articles published a century-plus after their own deaths, no less. Truly, her characters are marvels.
I'm boggled both by the CE defenders and by the people saying, "I guess I just don't understand exactly what plagiarism is or how to avoid it." There was even one ten or twenty-post threadlet going on about how it seemed really weird to call it plagiarism since some of the works might have fallen out of copyright so what did it matter anymore? To all of that I have no words, my own or anyone else's, just amazed and outraged sputtering.
Yes ... and I've sneered at her books every time I see one ever since.
But NR was also hurt - definitely emotionally, possibly financially - by the people who leapt to JD's defense. If I recall correctly, they kept telling her she was being mean ....
I think it would be funny if, in the fantasy future where I am a published author, someone accuses me of stealing all my jokes from some guy named "Polter-Cow" on the Internet.
I think it would be funny if, in the fantasy future where I am a published author, someone accuses me of stealing all my jokes from some guy named "Polter-Cow" on the Internet
Oh, don't think we won't. You dead-bovine thief, you.
That was her first book, IIRC.
As a racing-mad teen, it made me want to write a long, annoying letter detailing everything she got wrong, which was almost everything.
In that pre-Google era, accurate information on horse racing and breeding rules and regulations was still not hard to come by, drat it!
But I suppose I can forgive her for it. Mebbe.
(Yes, it is my Bullet Proof Pedantry!)
If I recall correctly, they kept telling her she was being mean ....
Like the girls who picked on them in High School?
Accusing someone of plagiarism rightfully is so nerdy and ugly and mean.
And, on the SBTB site, they had a plagairism expert of some sort who'd looked at the examples (or perhaps only one or two) and say it did look like plagairism ... and someone posted accusing him of slander.
It's very fan-girly in there.
I wonder how one becomes a plagiarism expert.
Dear God, plagiarism is a fucked-up word. -iari-? Are they trying to make sure that only people intelligent enough to spell it can accuse people of it?
hasn't stopped anyone so far ....
