Silver on the Tree absolutely is the worst of the five.

Greenwitch was my favorite, and I think I like Over Sea, Under Stone a little more in retrospect. And maybe even The Dark Is Rising is better in retrospect. If only because they're all better than The Grey King and Silver on the Tree.

Funny, because it was The Grey King that won all the awards. I actually like it a lot, because it's really spooky and atmospheric, and has all that tragic backstory associated with it.

The end of Silver on the Tree always annoys me, though: WHY do they have to forget everything? I'm not alone: every year there are a couple of Yuletide stories that "fix" that. Some of them are quite good, actually.

I actually like it a lot, because it's really spooky and atmospheric, and has all that tragic backstory associated with it.

There's some good stuff, but mostly it spends pages and pages on sheep and being Welsh with very little happening.

WHY do they have to forget everything?

Because mortals are dumb! Old Ones are the best! Being special is special!

You really didn't like The Grey King? I think that's the best, though I like The Dark Is Rising, personally. The Welsh connections really intrigued me. That's about all I remember from it, but it's enough to leave a positive takeaway anyhow.

I don't find myself recommending The Dark Is Rising very much these days, but it was important to me. In this modern age, with good fantasy series so much more prevalent, it's not as impressive.

You really didn't like The Grey King? I think that's the best

I know! But I didn't care for it. Cooper's pacing and narrative structure are just not my thing; characters seem to do nothing for pages and pages and then magically end up somewhere important, do something significant, and then be boring for pages and pages. There rarely seems to be any real conflict or active struggle.

The Welsh connections really intrigued me.

Whereas I didn't care. So that didn't help matters.

Heh. I think I was just like "Wait, what, Arthur legends have some interesting history to them? They're not just the Disney movie?"

I read it much younger than you.

Dance With Dragons: It's not enough that these books have eight thousand characters, now they're all disguised as each other?

I'm so tickled. Tim hauled ass through the 4th Skulduggery Pleasant book (Dark Days) in less than a week, and is now almost done with the 5th book (Mortal Coil). Two nights ago he asked me to hide it from him so he would go to bed at a reasonable time, since he had been reading until 2 or 3 every night.

WIN WIN WIN.

He hasn't quite gotten to the part where the Remnants infect everyone (no Tanith no no no), but he's almost there. Thank god. I need to flail at him about Tanith. Oh, and about Kenspeckle getting killed. He'll understand, especially about Kenspeckle, because Tim loves Kenspeckle.

I think when the 7th book arrives we might have a fight over who gets to read it first. (I'll win. I'm a hair-puller.)

A Game of Thrones : I was right. The one major death spoiler I knew, and it still hurt. I almost have tears in my eyes here, and I knew it was coming.