Knut and I both thought that NPR's List of Top 100 Science Fiction and Fantasy Books was incredibly boring.
So we traded picks and made our own top ten of just Fantasy and I like our list better. (They included series so we did too.)
1. The Circus of Dr. Lao - Charles Finney
2. Gormenghast Trilogy - Mervyn Peake
3. Lud-In-The-Mist - Hope Mirrlees
4. Mythago Wood series - Robert Holdstock
5. Land of Laughs - Jonathan Carroll
6. The Magic Toyshop - Angela Carter
7. Fafrhd and the Grey Mouser series - Fritz Leiber
8. Riddlemaster of Hed series - Patricia McKillip
9. The Dying Earth - Jack Vance
10. Iron Dragon's Daughter - Michael Swanick
Well, I've certainly read a more representative sample of the NPR list than y'all's.
Glen Weldon's commentary on the list is interesting, I think: [link]
Yeah, your list is completely foreign to me. I have heard of
Gormenghast,
and I have a Jonathan Carroll book that JZ lent me years ago (I think that's the one, actually) but I haven't read, but I haven't even heard of the rest.
There's much on the NPR list I haven't heard of either, but also lots I like. Too bad the
Feed
books didn't make it this time!
Glen Weldon's commentary on the list is interesting, I think: [link]
Ooh, yeah, worth a read.
I have the first book in the Gormenghast trilogy, but I've sadly never gotten around to reading it.
I haven't much on the NPR list either, sadly, but the books I have read Snow Crash, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, and some others) I've very much enjoyed.
I need to read more science fiction, is the moral of this story, I think!
I tried Gorgmenghast and it just seemed utterly bleak. I do enjoy Riddlemaster of Hed and I've heard of Mythago Woods, but the others are unfamiliar.
I've read a bunch of the books on your list David, but I don't necessarily agree they're the best ones. For instance, I think that Angela Carter's
The Bloody Chamber
collection is more important (and interesting!) than
The Magic Toyshop.
And while
Gormenghast
is hugely important, I don't know many people who've made it through the entire trilogy. (Heaven knows I haven't.)
Plus, no Tanith Lee? No Ray Bradbury? Crazyheads.
Zelazny would go on any list I made, if I was making lists.
Trying to read Gormenghast was a lot like dental surgery, except without the anesthesia.