So I guess the Hogwarts money is in some sort of trust?
Well, just after I started this argument discussion, I got to the parts in Book 5 where the Ministry keeps passing laws granting it more and more authority over the management of Hogwarts.
So I think the answer is that it's a publicly-funded or supported school with a semi-autonomous board of directors. Because it's at least sort of public (JKR never really specifies), the Ministry for Magic can interfere more and more with its operations. It's like the California Legislature granting state executives the ability to micromanage the state university system--somewhat unprecedented, but not outside their legal authority.
In other news, I cannot believe it took me until I heard the two words being spoken in proximity that I picked up on the Slytherin/slithering thing.
I just got it now!
I was very surprised to learn what 'muggles' was in the US in the 20s and 30s.
And do you know what phrase evolved into "Abracadabra"? I kept hoping a witch would remark on the insensitivity of muggles to use
that
word to represent magic being worked. Like how Earthlings have no idea about "Belgium".
I'll google Abracadabra and muggles if explain "Belgium".
I'll google Abracadabra and muggles
You don't have to google. What's the name of the Killing Curse in HP? Avada Kedavra.
You don't have to google. What's the name of the Killing Curse in HP? Avada Kedavra.
Wait, we're supposed to assume that "abracadabra" in the muggle world came from "Avada Kedavra"? Or is it explicitly said and I blew past it?
I assumed the similarity, but the other way round (i.e., "abracadabra" --> "Avada Kedavra") was meant to be a tongue-in-cheek play on words by Rowling the author, but not meant to reflect some Big Thing within the actual world of Harry Potter.
Wait, we're supposed to assume that "abracadabra" in the muggle world came from "Avada Kedavra"? Or is it explicitly said and I blew past it?
I haven't seen it explicitly said, I just assumed it based on the similarity. Dunno what Big Thing that could mean inside the world of the books, though. Although it's worth noting that it's the only curse I've seen so far that doesn't appear to be Latin in origin.
So I think the answer is that it's a publicly-funded or supported school with a semi-autonomous board of directors.
Hogwarts is a charter school!
I always assumed the "kedavra" was a play on "cadaver".
