P.M. Marcontell -- I hope I am not part of the reason why you feel like you should keep your mouth shut! I didn't mean to make you feel uncomfortable by joining the discussion, and I am sorry if I did.
Her Wes reads a little off (which may be my Uninvited Guest issue in a nutshell), however a large part of that is the fact that I'm a primarily Wescentric writer, so many, many Wesleys feel off to me. I'm hypercritical about the characters in which I'm most invested. (Wesley, Buffy, and, oddly, Fred, even though I don't write much Fred.)
It's true, the characters we feel most invested in as writers are often the hardest to accept someone else's vision of! I like most of the Wes in TUG (I love the Watchers, and not just because she made one of them a deconstructionist), but not the very end, because it's not something the Wesley I've written myself would want to do. Sometimes, you get a hold of a character in your head, and either other people's view of the character work with it or they don't. Then, there's the converse -- I have been writing a Smallville story for several months now that I have been having trouble with because it has to be told from Clark's point of view, and I found that, among other things, I really had a hard time writing Clark. I *don't* have him in my head the way I have Lex, or Wesley (theme much?), and so it took some doing to understand even my own version of him.
I do think Yahtzee is someone who has malleable characters - she's written a couple of different Buffys, for instance. I wonder if that's part of what PMM's noticing.
(Note that I do not think this is a bad thing, at all - I don't think she's ever written a Buffy that I disbelieved, and she's hard to do right and do right by.)
And the evil Farscape fans (whom I love) have now planted Giles meets Aeryn in my head and it won't go away! There is no sex but I think extensive intellectual warfare might work.
No no no, see, PMM's going to write Crichton/Wesley. Which I realize is kind of an uphill battle, but c'mon, Plei! You'll love it. It'll be fun! Just because it's a crossover with a fandom you're not in...
Mme Lizard? Insent.
Thanks, darling. I'll be full of the slashy Christmas cheer, or something.
I hope I am not part of the reason why you feel like you should keep your mouth shut! I didn't mean to make you feel uncomfortable by joining the discussion, and I am sorry if I did.
Hee. Well, feeling less of a misanthrope, now, and to be honest, it's sort of a pile of: comment somewhere and either a: have it become some larger discussion I hadn't intended or b: see the actual comment elsewhere outside of the original context or c: comment as part of an offhand set of comments and have it turn into more than that.
So, it's no one thing, rather a set of them that have been making me want to curl under my desk and say "never talking again. ever. ever." Plus, you know, holidays.
I do think Yahtzee is someone who has malleable characters - she's written a couple of different Buffys, for instance. I wonder if that's part of what PMM's noticing
It's partly that, and partly that when she has a firm grasp on a character, it's firm enough that a more slippery one stands out all the more. There have been Buffys I've believed completely, and a couple (TUG) where I didn't, at all. YBMV.
No no no, see, PMM's going to write Crichton/Wesley. Which I realize is kind of an uphill battle, but c'mon, Plei! You'll love it. It'll be fun! Just because it's a crossover with a fandom you're not in...
In the event that someone has decided to get me Farscape DVDs, this remains possible. SA, hon, if you're reading this... any progress on the HCL/AtS? You were the last one holding the ball. Pun intended.
t flicks through archives
t frowns
If someone writes me good Willow/Dru I will make them a very nice present.
Updated Hole in the Ground with two new(ish) stories. To be a woman, and Influence. The first is Buffy; second is Of Gods and Monsters.
To be a woman
I liked that. & am I right?:
Tara
Dawn
Buffy
Will
Anya
Ayup. Cool, it came through. Glad it wasn't obscure.
EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!
NEW RESOLUTION!!!
Okay. Dan and Casey came to Christmas at MY HOUSE. Dan and Casey will be living in sin in my Sampo.
DAN AND CASEY WILL BE MY NEW BLACK!!! I WILL BE WRITING DAN AND CASEY, BECAUSE THEY HAVE A LOVE THAT IS TRUE, AND RIGHT, AND GOOD!!!!
Sorry. Caught up in the excitement of OTPs past.