The Chicago Tribune's TV reviewers have their Top Ten of 2005 list up. I think that most Buffistas will be pleased:
[The list is alphabetical.] "Battlestar Galactica," Sci Fi: There's no antiseptic, morally upright future on display here. Just a lot of confused, conflicted people, in a battle to the death with "others" who look exactly like humans - and who say they are representatives of the one true God. The real joke on those who think "Galactica" is just another sci-fi show is that this gripping drama is, in fact, television's most topical, incisive commentary on current events in our very troubled world.
"Deadwood," HBO: A slimy mix of Shakespeare, Dickens and "The Sopranos" in the Old West, this drama got deeper and uglier in its second season. Calamity Jane may have donned a dress, but Deadwood itself seemed even more mired in animalism, corruption and, thanks to the gut-wrenching death of young William Bullock, a world incapable of sustaining innocence.
"Everybody Hates Chris," UPN: Somehow the words "sitcom family" have come to mean dumb, dumpy dad, needling mom and sassy, irritating children. Thank goodness this refreshing half-hour comedy came along to redeem the prototypical sitcom family and help rescue the genre from clichés and tired joke-telling. The jokes work on "Chris" because the characters, based on comic Chris Rock's real family, feel entirely real, and the situations that young Chris goes through - as a black kid at an all-white school - are fresh and compelling.
"Grey's Anatomy," ABC: One of TV's most delicious treats, a habit-forming mix of romantic hanky panky - call it intern swapping - and sometimes outrageous, almost surreal medical black comedy and moral debate. Wrap the entire cast up as Christmas gifts, including believable everywoman Ellen Pompeo, lovably cantankerous Sandra Oh, scary-strict Chandra Wilson and Patrick Dempsey, the neurosurgeon who's all too accurately nicknamed "Dr. McDreamy."
"House," Fox: If it wanted to, this medical drama could rest on its significant strengths - its magnetic lead, Hugh Laurie, and its ability to, each week, to wrap a compelling moral quandary inside a dramatic medical mystery. But "House" often finds a way to upend expectations; stellar episodes have played with timelines, points of view and the notion of who is a "hero" - any medical drama that does not automatically make a kid with cancer a sappy saint is certainly an audacious and ambitious piece of work.
"Lost," ABC: Sometimes hokey, sometimes silly, sometimes confounding in its flashbacks, it's TV's most original, deservedly Emmy-winning offering, irresistible watching that just about doubled its stash of castaways this second season and just about doubled the pleasure. Fantasy, adventure, thriller suspense, romance, comedy and even, at times, profound human drama amidst blue skies, aquamarine seas and a not-so-friendly paradise.
"My Name is Earl," NBC: The winning new saga of a likable rogue once destined for hell and now hell-bent on redemption. The always interesting Jason Lee wins a long overdue star turn and, as low-brow and low in principle Joy, Jaime Pressly is turning in one of the smartest, funniest performances this season. The sitcom, if that's what this original show is, survives.
"Rome," HBO: Epic, seductive storytelling blending history, tragedy and murky melodrama, played out alternately on dazzling sets and in the grimiest of alleyways, echoing its themes of the sublime and carnal in human nature. Great writing, great acting, great cliffhangers and the grandest of passions.
"The Shield," FX: "The Shield" was already one of TV's boldest dramas when it brought Glenn Close to the party. Close went toe to toe with charismatic star Michael Chiklis and the rest of the top-notch "Shield" cast last season, and the results were simply incendiary. When the show returns in January, Forest Whitaker will play an investigator who threatens to take down Vic Mackey's Strike Team; Whitaker has some pretty big (continued...)