I think I liked it. I don't get it, but I like it.

Except the whole no name business, which is just tiresome.

Juliebird, your commentary sounds like my friend watching last night until we could no longer make sounds and just rolled eyes.

I did not like last night's episode, but I am wondering one thing:

what are we supposed to believe about the smoke monster?

a) that Jacob created him?

b) that the monster was already there, but that Jacob's brother's "soul" was absorbed in him?

My guess is "b" because Jacob's dead mother appeared to him, and I assume that was the smoke monster. But maybe the brother is just Hurley.

Clearly Jacob's role is to lay violence to any visitors who get too close to the light, so I guess that partially explains the animosity between Dharma and the Others.

Did Jacob's adoptive mother have super strength and super powers? How did she raze a small village and fill in the underground cave and move the brother's body all before nightfall?

So I guess, as has been speculated, the little boy Smokey's been seeing is Jacob (or a vision/hallucination of same).

And, thank the lord, it looks like the island isn't purgatory. That would have been more eye-roll-y.

Also, I'm thankful the light from the cave wasn't red, or I'd be expecting Clifford the Big Red Ball to turn up at the bottom.

Mostly, the only thing that really bugged was witholding a name for Smokey. As -t said, very tiresome.

Here's a link to my recaplet (the short write-up). [link]

Blergh.

b) that the monster was already there, but that Jacob's brother's "soul" was absorbed in him?

Yep. Fate worse than death.

Did Jacob's adoptive mother have super strength and super powers? How did she raze a small village and fill in the underground cave and move the brother's body all before nightfall?

Maybe she was Smokey before. Hence how she knew about the fate worse than death.

I don't understand how she could have been Smokey before, because she had a living body that "Esau" was able to kill.

Yeah, I don't know how to explain that either.

Don't get me wrong, I don't understand anything any more than I did before the episode, but I found it compellingly watchable. I gave up on answers a while ago, I think.

I enjoyed it. I'm quite bemused as to why fans all over the internet are losing the plot (no semi-pun intended) over it. Yes, the light in the cave was a bit irritating at first, but by the end I was into the whole thing where the island is a Garden of Eden, source-of-all-life type setup. (I was less keen on the anvil that was the LOOK, THESE ARE THE ADAM AND EVE PEOPLE, NO REALLY, LOOK, THEY ARE ending. But you can't have everything.)

I think there are two kinds of LOST fans, and The Girl and I are the wrong kind. As we were just saying on the phone, we'd much prefer a LOST that featured no one but Hurley, Desmond, Faraday, Widmore, that spooky woman Fionnula Flanagan plays whose name I'm bored of looking up, and Jacob and Esau. And was all about the epic, not the adventure. We may be watching the wrong show. Just don't tell us that.