I was baptized as an infant and confirmed at age 12. The former was more of "welcome this child into the church" and the latter was "this person has made the choice to become a Christian in the Methodist tradition." I think both can have a place. I also think that 12 is kind of young to make decisions on where you'll spend the rest of your spiritual life. But then, I'm biased in as much as my confirmation didn't "take".

ETA: Which makes it sound like my confirmation was faulty in some way, and I don't really mean that. I mean that I don't think I really had enough life experience at that point to make an educated commitment to a spiritual path.

I also think that 12 is kind of young to make decisions on where you'll spend the rest of your spiritual life.

Yeah, I agree. But I think it's pretty much standard, or even a bit late. Mormon kids join at 7, and I forget what age Catholic kids are confirmed at.

Oh, that reminds me. I was skimming through Showtime listings the other day and one of the movies they have coming up is apparently a Mormon version of Pride and Prejudice.

I was baptized as an infant and confirmed at age 12. The former was more of "welcome this child into the church" and the latter was "this person has made the choice to become a Christian in the Methodist tradition."

That's my experience (Presbyterian, and later UCC).

and later UCC

United Church of Christ? As in the "we welcome everyone" commercials? I have such a love on for everything I've heard about that denomination. If I could get past my basic theological issues with Trinitarian doctrine I might be looking for a local congregation.

I was baptized at 8 or 9. In some ways that's young, I suppose, but I understood what it meant and wanted it. There wasn't a specific age at which you were supposed to be baptized, because it was all about becoming a believer (usually couched in the Baptist buzz-phrases "ask Jesus into your heart" or "make a decision for Christ"), though I never knew of a child being baptized younger than 6 or 7, and children raised in the church who hadn't "made the decision" by age 12 or so got a certain amount of pressure/attention from pastors and Sunday School teachers.

If I could get past my basic theological issues with Trinitarian doctrine

What's that? I mean, what's Trinitarian doctrine? Belief in the separateness of God, Jesus and the Holy Spirit?

I also think that 12 is kind of young to make decisions on where you'll spend the rest of your spiritual life.

Well, its not like they hold you to it with guns or something.

I think its more a rite of passage. You're raised in a tradition and then they respect that you're old enough to embrace it consciously.

Raq, I really like the "we don't practice infant baptism" answer. It's true and concise and politely ends a discussion that is potentially yet not necessarily nosy.

If I could get past my basic theological issues with Trinitarian doctrine I might be looking for a local congregation.

I've always held what turns out to be (roughly) the Eastern Orthodox assessment of "it's a mystery. relax already."

I was baptized as a baby - i think both of my younger sisters were done later . and I was confirmed. amd it didn't take. The concept of Immersion squicks me - too dramatic. but that is just those WASP roots showing.

now, I am trying to decided weather or not to go into work. I have a cold, but it isn't really bad. But resting for a day is good for me. but if Iam not feeeling bad, I should go to work. but I will be spreading germs... this is the new england work ethic conflicting with sensible one that the WorkEthic thinks is a slacker.