Hmm. I actually don't know. She mentioned it in passing on her LJ, and knowing her, I think it was probably just a colourful description of how well-known the song'd have to be.
Willow ,'Conversations with Dead People'
Buffista Music III: The Search for Bach
There's a lady plays her fav'rite records/On the jukebox ev'ry day/All day long she plays the same old songs/And she believes the things that they say/She sings along with all the saddest songs/And she believes the stories are real/She lets the music dictate the way that she feels.
"Emo" is such a loaded word, as others have mentioned. If she actually wants a song that's about personal sorrow (rather than something from a band labeled "emo" that isn't actually emo), I'm reminded of Dashboard Confessional's "Vindicated." Though I can't imagine a toy that someone would put that song in.
If the search is for the genre name, rather than the content, I'd suggest "Sugar We're Going Down" or "Dance, Dance", both by Fall Out Boy, and both of which were big enough singles that they would merit the level of fame to end up in a toy. But neither really have that "emo" feel, they're much more pop-punk.
The intended usage for this information would make it so much easier to guess! I have probably not been helpful.
What about I'm Not Okay? by MCR? The video definitely has the outcast thing going on, and it's pretty well known. It's more defiant than morose, though.
Sleep has more of the faux-suicide vibe.
For Fall Out Boy, I'd say Hum Hallelujah, especially given that it was partially inspired by an attempted OD by Pete Wentz.
To usher in the end of WFMU's 50th Anniversary year (and two years of free NYC shows we've been involved with), we're happy to announce the latest upcoming WFMU Free Concert Series event, and one we're producing fully: Wire will be playing at the Fillmore at Irving Plaza in Manhattan on October 9th
NYistas! There is a benefit for an old friend of mine at the Bowery Ballroom on 8/26. It's a tuesday (also my birthday) and I don't think I can make it up for it but it looks like a fun time (Victoria Williams, Richard Buckner...okay maybe not fun but good music!):
Alice Cooper's first two albums, long out of print and I'm not even sure if they've ever been out on DVD, are back in print!
Pretties for You is late psychedelia, but Easy Action is the cool lost album worth pursuing. Great hard rock from 1970 with a pronounced Who influence.
Free track from the new Byrne/Eno album: [link]
Their first collaboration since the awesome My Life in the Bush of Ghosts.
I enjoyed MLitBoG but I found that new track pretty dull.
I met REM's manager as we were walking our kindergarteners to school just now. I live in a weird little tiny town.
t madly searches for Stand In The Place Where You Live joke with which to earworm the thread