Here is my take: Individual effort (non-governmental) was and is more effective in the Katrina thing. Everything government has done around this has been a disaster, impeding individual effort.

Government? Bad, in this situation.

I don't think so. My primary beef with the Federal government (I'm not a Louisiana resident, so I don't feel like I get to complain about the Louisiana staties and the New Orleans locals) is that it took them too long to act, and that at first, they seemed paralyzed. It seemed clear to me t font ="Mondy Morning QB" that the state and city officials were going to be incapacitated, if they got the big one, and it seems to me like that should have been obvious to the all levels of government, even before the the storm struck. I see this as an issue of incompetence, shameful, deadly incompetence.

Here, however, is my question: What natural forces of the marketplace were missing for the people in the Domes?

Supply.

Nilly- Don't feel bad. I must have read those books every couple years, and until my sister pointed out all the religious stuff right to my face, I never saw it in any of the Narnia books.

Still, when I read it don't always still connect the two, just because I know now.

But then again when I went and saw Star wars this summer I must have been to wrapped up in Darth Vader's story to get all the supposed and according to the press very blatent attacks on the goverment in it. I guess that can be considered niave?

Nilly- Don't feel bad. I must have read those books every couple years, and until my sister pointed out all the religious stuff right to my face, I never saw it in any of the Narnia books.

Heck, I didn't see it until I was in my 40's. And that was because I was analyzing the series from the perspective of a history of science class that talked about the development of scientific methods and how prior ones (Aristotelian and Platonic) were or weren't absorbed into the philosophy of the middle ages because of the emphasis on Christianity in natural philosophy. It really opened my eyes to subtext or even plain old text that can be overlooked when you're not reading for it. Or, is so much part of your everyday life that you absorb it as normal without second thought.

I'm pretty sure my mother told me about it when I was pretty young, but I did not see it at first. A nice thing about the stories though, is that they're still lovely stories, whether the religious ideas they can reference mean anything to you, or not.

I'd totally go to Narnia in a heartbeat. Sunnydale? Not so much.

The Coast Guard is part of of the government, and they just rocked like a rocking thing.

Yip. It was a great relief to see that the Coast Guard guy who ran point on rescue is now running the relief effort.

Imagine that: someone who's been trained for decades to respond to sudden emergency situations and organize communications/chain of command, and is actually capable at all of the above. How did he ever get promoted with this administration in charge?

Well, apparently he impressed everybody who dealt with him in the crisis. The cream occasionally rises to the top.

The cream occasionally rises to the top.

Yeah, as long as they don't leave it there to spoil.

In all actuality, the military promotion system is probably one of the least affected by croniism and nepotism you can find. It still happens, but the Pendleton Act did it's best to put a crimp in it. The biggest problem I saw in the military is that there a still a lot of discriminatory stereotypes in it that can hold people back.

I read the Narnia books when I was a young teen. I was about halfway through one of them - don't recall the exact passage that did it - when I realized they were a Christian allegory. It took all the enjoyment out of them for me. I felt like I'd been manipulated.

It will be interesting to see the Narnia movie when it comes out. As a 10-year old, I didn't see any of the Christian imagery at all. I'll be curious to see how the screenwriter deals with it. Whether they emphasize it or try to eliminate it or just kind of let it ride where it's at. Also, I'll be curious to see how I'll react to it. Even once I could see it, it didn't annoy me or anything and I don't, by any means, consider myself "Christian." I really am pretty oblivious that way.