Synechdochic's "Freedom's Just Another Word for Nothing Left to Lose" won in a GEN category?!?
Well, I actually talked to her about that. And, well, it's more gen than it is slash, really. In the sense that the story is about Rodney and Atlantis and everything he's learned, more than it is about Rodney-and-John.
And the writer picks the category, but you are limited to the categories they make available to you. If I'd put Wartime in the gen category I would have been able to put it in Action-Adventure, and would probably have had a better chance of winning than in Multiples-Series, which was very small, but which people were reading for the multiple-snogging rather than for the plot. Or so I suspect.
But Wartime isn't a gen series, except in tone and plottiness: it does indeed have a fairly explicit threesome, and so I was pretty much doomed regardless. ::shrugs::
Anyway, thanks Matt.
No accounting for taste, indeed.