Strega, the reason the t-shirt thing has something to do with it is this;

I remember in the B5 usenet groups, occasionally someone would pop in to tell JMS about some unauthorized merchandise for sale, so he could sic Warner Bros on 'em. See, because they were fans, some of them thought that it was a bad thing to steal from the people who made the thing they liked. We've come so far since then.

Right there, you're (I think) comparing JMS trying to stop unauthorized sale of material with fan responsibility, saying the Serenity fans are irresponsible in that they don't try to make the mother ship profit like B5 fans did. To my knowledge, JMS has never touched t-shirts. So, in the context of this case, I don't think it can be compared.

There is an argument to be made that t-shirts effectively promote free advertising for the company owning a franchise, and that advertising is more valuable than fixed rate licensing. Of course, Universal never went down that route, which I think is a shame. I'm pretty sure it happened with Snakes On A Plane recently -- they allowed printing of shirts etc -- but that was hardly the box office smash either.

I think Strega's point was that, once upon a time, fans were outraged when unauthorized people tried to make a profit off their asses and that it's not so much the case anymore.

Kevin -- I was comparing what some fans did, not what JMS did. That's why I said just that in my previous post.

For the record, in the newsgroup JMS repeatedly mentioned which companies sold licensed T-shirts, and that anyone else was selling pirated merchandise, but again: what he did or didn't do is irrelevant to what I was talking about. And honestly, I think it's beyond pedantic to claim that only examples involving T-shirts have any bearing in this conversation.

There is an argument to be made that t-shirts effectively promote free advertising for the company owning a franchise, and that advertising is more valuable than fixed rate licensing. Of course, Universal never went down that route, which I think is a shame.

Maybe they don't believe that it's more valuable, then. And/or maybe they understand that failing to defend their rights, regardless of whether or not the "free advertising" is worth something, makes it easy for any other unlicensed vender to claim that the subject matter is public domain.

Licensed Serenity shirts: [link] [link]

11thHour's "original art" shirts (still for sale): [link] and starting to understand the demand more and more.

Google cache of stuff that's now removed: [link] [link] [link]

Google cache of 11thHour advertising her stuff to FF/Serenity fans: [link]

I don't know if there's a litmus test

I'm pretty sure there isn't. I've talked it over with a few copyright pros, and each company seeking permission has different thresholds after which they do seek permission. (E.g., 1 line plus title from a poem, 150 words from an essay, but 300 words from a published book.)

It's a little irritating -- you only find out the niggling details of copyright law by a lawsuit actually happening. This would explain why so many people say, "Copyright? What copyright?" when photocopying a whole book for a for-profit research project.

(This really happened, many times.)

I think Strega's point was that, once upon a time, fans were outraged when unauthorized people tried to make a profit off their asses and that it's not so much the case anymore.

Yeah, I reread it all (again) will confirm I'm an idiot and had added my own world into Strega's phrasing, so sorry. Although, the reason fans profit from SERENITY is complex, but it's definitely there more than other fandoms I've seen. (Example: ebaying advanced screening tickets for $200 each, which happened pretty much hundreds of times in 2005).

Also, Universal have told the law firm to drop the case against Susan. She's free to keep sellin'.

I'd heard that the case was resolved but I hadn't realized that they'd told her she could continue selling.

Well, they've said the designs left are okay from Universal's point o' view. Which I'd agree with.

FYI - Morena Baccarin is going to be on How I Met Your Mother tonight. (omg!girl!crush!)

And Nathan is on Lost on Wednesday. Adam's new show starts the following Wednesday.