Also want to know what Black & White game is. And how it relates to bear poop. (oops, xpost with the husband)

And, I don't think that the refusal to leave had anythign to do with logic (i.e., posting sentries, schlepping water, etc) and everything to do with emerging island politcs. I don't think that Sayid and Sawyer want to follow Jack anywhere- I think that would definitely cement Jack as the leader. Also, even if someone was tending the fire while everyone else nested in the caves, that definitely points to settling in for a long haul - and I don't think that the people who stayed on the beach are able to deal with that yet. They want to keep believing that theory, therefore, can't physically move. But I think it has more to do with not wanting to follow the leader, or at least protesting Jack's de facto leadership. (at least for Kate, Sayid, and Sawyer). I'm interested in why no one brought up the monster as a deterrant to going inland.

Regarding schlepping water- I wonder what will happen when those who control the water cut off the supply. You know it's going to happen. And, I wonder why it will happen. Wheee!

I want to know what Jin did before going to work for Sun's father,

He was a waiter, wasn't he?

and if she never knew what her father's business really was

I think she got a pretty good idea when Jin came home all bloody.

I think she knew before- I got a horrified vibe when he told her that he had to work for her father.

I did too -- plus she was trying to warn him about her father when he told her that he was going to ask him for permission.

(Wasn't that incoherent?)

and if someone is taking care of her dog

She asked the lady who was setting her up to escape to take care of the dog. That worried me from the moment Jin gave her the puppy. Who's dog sitting?!

I liked how they used the dog going from wee pup to grown to show the passage of time.

The breaking the group into Cave vs. Beach dwellers seemed too contrived to me. I'm with the ones thinking it would make more sense to all go to the caves but have several people guarding the fire in shifts.

Hurley pissed me off this ep. First, still calling Jin "the Chinese guy" and then playing his discman while Charlie was playing guitar. Rude! I wonder when will get his story.

and if she never knew what her father's business really was

I think she got a pretty good idea when Jin came home all bloody.

After rewatching, I think she knew before then. She tells Jin that he doesn't know her father in the discussion at the party about eloping, and when he says he is going to work for her father and can suddenly afford an expensive ring, one of her reactions was clearly fear.

one of her reactions was clearly fear

The actress playing Sun has the most beautifully expressive face.

I'm interested in why no one brought up the monster as a deterrant to going inland.

Me too. Jack did refer to being able to "defend" or "set up defenses" which may have been in reference to the monster. But, since no one knows exactly what it is or what it can do (other than pull the pilot out of the cockpit and kill him bloodily), I don't get why Jack thinks the cave in the jungle where the monster has been is more secure than the beach where the monster has yet to visit.

Well, the skeletons suggest that the bodies were there undisturbed for many years.

Heh. There's an interview with Maggie Grace who plays Shannon at tvguide.com today and she says the cast sits around speculating about what's going to happen and, in particular, what the epileptic trees really are. She says,

Dominic thinks it's an elephant with cats duct-taped to it.

Makes sense to me!