Okay, I started watching the first episode again and when Jack is asking Kate to help him sew up his wound, he specifically says, "I'm a doctor, but I just can't reach it."

So... ?

And I don't see Locke as a visionary at all. He's too much of a pragmatist. A meat and potatoes kind of guy, who doesn't believe in magic, even though he thinks the island is special in that regard.

I think Locke has the potential to become rather dangerously insane, which would map him more closely to Cowslip than Fiver.

I also hope that Jack's not really a doctor, or he's very recently a doctor, or that he lost his license somehow, or, well, really anything to take him down a couple of pegs. Right now, his only flaw is low self-esteem, and even that seems to have been resolved.

I also hope that Jack's not really a doctor, or he's very recently a doctor, or that he lost his license somehow, or, well, really anything to take him down a couple of pegs.

I don't know about that being resolved, so much as he's accepted the mantle of responsibility. People can be responsable and still plauged with doubts and have low self esteem. Unless the island truly is magic.

I wonder how long before they name the island.

I hope they get the clearance for a Gilligan joke.

Or maybe someone can joke about naming it "Charlie's Island" as a very sideways jab at him being the Gilligan analog....

Or not...

They could name it "Nomanisan."

I've said it before, but I hope once they get settled into the housing situation, they start deciding to at least map the perimeter of the island.

It seems to be a fairly big island.

Me, I wouldn't set out to map the perimeter until I had a reliable souce for water. I would, however, have already started making a map of the area as I scouted it. They've already discovered several things that need to be kept track of. Not the least, that big cliff over the gorge where Jack fell down and nearly broke his crown. Let's not forget where that thing is.

Re: the flashback to the airport check-in. I think the absence of Sun from the line-up isn't significant. Jin's behaviour on the island indicates that he considers it is his job to take care of Sun, particularly by taking over any interaction with others.

Me, I wouldn't set out to map the perimeter until I had a reliable souce for water.

You mean like the one Jack found this week? The waterfall into the pond with the sunken doll.

Yep, exactly. Drownded Doll Crick. Within a day's hike from the beach camp, and probably within a relatively short hike from other parts of the beach, which allows the explorers to set up camps as they move around the perimeter, and they don't have to carry a month's worth of water with them as they move. They can scout the interior as well as the perimeter, and find more sources of fresh water, which will allow them to safely move even farther from the base camp.

As long as they know which fish and fruits they can eat.

I don't know about "not good," It was pretty much what it meant to be. A lightweight, "lets have fun withthe afterlife" kind of movie. It's not fantastic, but I'd still put it on the "good" side of the good/bad divide.

Step off on the Beetlejuice disrespect! This is insano crazytalk. It's like you don't even understand the virtue of wide stripes in production design.