Then again, if he hadn't, Charlie would be dead for real.

I dunno. Ethan said that they may not have hung Charlie if Jack hadn't insisted on forging ahead. We don't really have any evidence that he was lying about that.

I have a feeling that the screams he heard were sort of like the sound of ice clinking in a glass that he heard when the body of his dad walked past his campfire that one night.

So, Jack hears dead people?

Ethan said that they may not have hung Charlie if Jack hadn't insisted on forging ahead. We don't really have any evidence that he was lying about that.

Yup, Charlie was probably there to buy escape time in either of two ways- either Jack does what Ethan says and stops with the following, or Charlie is hung, ensuring that anyone following would stop and take the time to get him down.

Ethan said that they may not have hung Charlie if Jack hadn't insisted on forging ahead. We don't really have any evidence that he was lying about that.

Good point. So going on ahead was really a bad idea then.

Ethan said that they may not have hung Charlie if Jack hadn't insisted on forging ahead. We don't really have any evidence that he was lying about that.

Except the fact that he's *psycho* and really? Why else did he take Charlie? If he was important to have, Jack and Kate following wouldn't have sealed his fate. No, Charlie was there as a ruse, and the bandages were planted to make the searchers follow Ethan, while others dragged Claire off the other way.

Charlie was marked for bait the moment Ethan showed up at the end of the previous episode. The main logical course of action (albieit clouded by insanity) was to use him as bait, then use him to demoralize the pursuers. Ethen chose to "warn" Jack with the express purpose of following through and "picking" Charlie. He thought they would still think Claire was with and once Charlie was discovered, they would be slowed down and then stopped.

I also think Ethan didn't care if Charlie lived or died. If he wanted him dead, he would have snapped his neck or killed him and left him on the trail dead by some other way. But no, he hung the limp Charlie from a low-ish hanging wad of vines and took off. He knew Charlie could die, he just didn't give a damn. His plan was distraction and demoralization.

Good point. So going on ahead was really a bad idea then.

I will have to disagree. Generally when you have a pregnant woman and another person kidnapped by a psycho, you have to assume they were taken for some reason.

I'm not saying Jack was firing on all thrusters, but his instincts were half and half in that if they did not keep going, it wouldn't matter. Just a chance that they could rescue Claire and Charlie before the psycho did anything was probably in his mind.

It wasn't a great idea to keep following, but Ethan had been lying to them for three weeks, there is no indications that he would keep his word now.

I agree that Ethan didn't care if he were dead or alive- but his method was specific in order to take the most possible time- of course Jack would get him down, which would take time, and to revive him.

I agree that Ethan didn't care if he were dead or alive- but his method was specific in order to take the most possible time- of course Jack would get him down, which would take time, and to revive him.

Exactly. That's part of what I meant about not caring whether he lived or died. Had he broken Charlie's neck, Jack wouldn't have tried, and Ethen would still be pursued.

ETA: And Charlie did die, it's just that Jack revived him.

And, since Charlie hadn't seen what happened to Claire, he wouldn't pose any sort of threat even if he lived.

Re-watching now:

- Yes, 17th IS very good!

I want to know about Hurley so very, very much. I really do think that Walt will get that $20,000 someday.

Well, I mean, I can think of ways to distract my followers which are as distracting as a hanging, or moreso. Actually, they involve things like unconsciousness and/or bloody head wounds, neither of which takes a long time to prepare, and both of which leave the followers with a big ole floppy body to deal with. Unconscious or just woozy/bleeding, Charlie is a huge impediment to the followers; dead, he could be much less of an impediment. Depending on how Kate and Jack react to obviously-dead people, and considering Jack's a doctor, I think he can probably be pretty dispassionate about, say, finding Charlie's decapitated head on a spike.

If they had brought Charlie down off the hanging tree, and thumped him for 30 minutes, and stil got nothing, well, he would have been dead and that would have sucked, but Jack and Kate could have kept on looking. The real 'impediment' to their searching was that Charlie lived.

In sum, this is the same reason why bullets are designed to spin sloppily: a living and wounded comrade is more work to deal with than a dead one.