Spike ,'Sleeper'
This thread is a focused discussion group. Please see the first post below for the current topic and upcoming book discussions. While natter will inevitably happen, we encourage you to treat this like a virtual book club and try to keep your posts in that spirit.
By consensus, this thread is reopened specifically to discuss Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It will be closed again once that discussion has run its course.
***SPOILER ALERT***
Just finished The Gift of Asher Lev.
Such a good book. Not quite as good as the first.
Wolfram or Hil, (or anyone else), are the Ladover basically the Lubbavitcher? At one point Asher's father lists criticisms by other Hasids (too involved with the secular, too evangelical, a few others) that remind me of things I've heard. Also, Schneerson died without a successor... though that happened several years after the book was published and not unforseeable at the point that it was. Any thoughts?
Wolfram or Hil, (or anyone else), are the Ladover basically the Lubbavitcher? At one point Asher's father lists criticisms by other Hasids (too involved with the secular, too evangelical, a few others) that remind me of things I've heard. Also, Schneerson died without a successor... though that happened several years after the book was published and not unforseeable at the point that it was. Any thoughts?
Well it's difficult for me to tell since the book was written in 1972 and I'm not really familiar with the Lubavitchers from that time, although if you google "Ladover Hasid" you'll find a couple of websites that say just that. But the current Lubavitcher Hassidus has changed quite significantly since their Rebbe died.
But the current Lubavitcher Hassidus has changed quite significantly since their Rebbe died.
They have and ( GoAL Spoiler): the rifts seem similar to what Asher described as possible if he didn't let his son stay with his parents. Again, not unforseeable but a little spooky in light of the thing happening fifteen years after he wrote the book.
Trudy asked my question.
I am finding the book wonderful, but painful. I hurt so for young Asher, that I can't rush through it. And I hurt for his mother too, even though I wanted to shake her. And just reading about Siberia makes me wonder about the color of ice. And och.
I just checked. Menachem Schneerson died in 1994. The Gift of Asher Lev was published four years earlier.
I'm pretty sure the Ladover are supposed to be the Lubavitcher. In addition to a lot of other similarities, there's the phrase repeated several times of the Rebbe wearing an "ordinary dark hat." (In the forties and fifties, the Lubavitcher Rebbe deviated from tradition and started wearing a regular sort of hat, the kind most men wore then, while most of the other Chasidic sects were wearing the much older style of hats. There's a scene in The Chosen at somebody's wedding or bar mitzvah, where all the Rebbes from the various Chasidic sects in Brooklyn walk in, and they're described as mostly a crowd of old men in traditional clothing, and one younger man in an ordinary hat.)
Also, the few lines right near the end of My Name is Asher Lev, where Asher's father is talking about reaching out to questioning Jewish students on college campuses, is exactly what the Lubavitch were doing then.
I hate bringing up administrative stuff, but we still don't have a book to follow Small World. I think the last consensus was that we'd make a list of Buffistas who volunteer to choose a book for the club, and find some random way to choose one. Does that sound right?
What is the discussion date for Small World ?
October 11.
And who is the author of Small World?