This thread is a focused discussion group. Please see the first post below for the current topic and upcoming book discussions. While natter will inevitably happen, we encourage you to treat this like a virtual book club and try to keep your posts in that spirit.
By consensus, this thread is reopened specifically to discuss Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It will be closed again once that discussion has run its course.
***SPOILER ALERT***
- **Spoilers for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows lie here. Read at your own risk***
Well, Snape is addressed as Professor Snape, and yet it seems like he pretty much went right from Hogwarts to Death Eater to teacher. There would have been about three or four years between him finishing schooling at Hogwarts and becoming a teacher there. And Tom Riddle seemed to think that there was at least a possibility that he could get a job as a Hogwarts teacher with no formal education after Hogwarts.
But on the other hand, we know that there are academic journals. And for those to exist, there generally need to be people who spend most of their time studying stuff.
Maybe 'Professor' is just a title you get when you become a teacher?
Maybe 'Professor' is just a title you get when you become a teacher?
This is my thinking. Oddly, I just assumed that Lupin's suitcase had recently been labeled, not that he'd come from another school.
I think Remus' suitcase is largely labeled for the purposes of exposition.
I like the theory, though, that he was tutoring students. I also like the idea that James and Sirius and Peter gave him a luggage tag (whatever the magical equivalent of that is) as a joke when they all graduated, because they were always ribbing him about being studious and professorly.
Also, I checked the HP Lexicon, and they have no information for Remus during those years.
[link]
The only note is that it's not long before his time at Hogwarts that Snape discovers the Wolfsbane potion. It must have been a pretty sad time for Remus, without his friends to keep him company during his transformations.
blows nose
God, poor bloody Remus. He had a pretty crappy deal, didn't he? And no sooner reunited with Sirius than he lost him again. God. Poor bastard.
I also like the idea that James and Sirius and Peter gave him a luggage tag (whatever the magical equivalent of that is) as a joke when they all graduated, because they were always ribbing him about being studious and professorly.
Even better!
He had a pretty crappy deal, didn't he? And no sooner reunited with Sirius than he lost him again. God. Poor bastard.
And it just got worse! Remus was definitely JK's Jossian element. I will make you love him and then make you suffer for loving him. A lot.
Man, do I love Remus. Poor Remus.
Does the foe glass show your enemies as you believe them to be or would it show enemies you didn't know you had?
Trying to figure out the logic of the Time Turner. There's a scene in PoA where Hermione misses a Charms class. It seems that the plan for that period was for her to go to Divination, then use the Time Turner to get back to the beginning of that class period, and then go to Charms. But she forgot to go to Charms, and fell asleep in the common room. After class, Harry and Ron found her and asked why she hadn't been in Charms. What was to stop her from using the Time Turner at that point to get back to the beginning of the period and get to Charms?
