'War Stories'
This thread is a focused discussion group. Please see the first post below for the current topic and upcoming book discussions. While natter will inevitably happen, we encourage you to treat this like a virtual book club and try to keep your posts in that spirit.
By consensus, this thread is reopened specifically to discuss Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It will be closed again once that discussion has run its course.
***SPOILER ALERT***
Makes me wonder if, to get into Slytherin, you had to turn around and punch a classmate.
Hee! Sadly, they also had a password.
Ya know, I was really kind of hoping that Draco and Harry would have ended up as allies/friends, etc. I thought she might have been foreshadowing that when in the song the Sorting Hat sings at the beginning of OotP, they mention Slytherin and Griffyndor being the best of friends.
Course, Lily and Severus kind of fill that role nicely, also.
I would be in Hufflepuff.
That was another thing I loved, the password as question for Ravenclaw.
I loved this, too.
I kept waiting for their to be some good Slytherins. And I am trying to parse why Hermione is in Gryffindor and Luna in Ravenclaw. I would say, even though Luna is "looney", she is just as brave as Hermione.
Makes me wonder if, to get into Slytherin, you had to turn around and punch a classmate.
Or shank 'em.
Slytherin: "Hey, lemme in, I gotta go to the bathroom. Stupid painting are you--GAAAHHH!!!"
Slytherin Classmate Behind First Slytherin: (as door opens) "Hidden shiv in the wand. Works every time."
And I am trying to parse why Hermione is in Gryffindor and Luna in Ravenclaw. I would say, even though Luna is "looney", she is just as brave as Hermione.
Yeah, Hermione seems to be much more of a Ravenclaw.
Although I liked the riddle idea, it doesn't seem to be very secure. I guess, though, the idea is that if you're clever enough to figure it out, you deserve entry to the tower, whether or not you're actually a Ravenclaw.
Yeah, Hermione seems to be much more of a Ravenclaw.
And surely Cedric was both brave and smart.
Not really sure about the essentialism of the sorting hat.
Not really sure about the essentialism of the sorting hat.
It seems like Ravenclaw and Gryffindor are sort of interchangable, while Hufflepuff and Slytherin are one-dimensional. Also, was Peter Pettigrew a Gryffindor, too?
Maybe there was another way into the Ravenclaw tower.
"Which came first the phoenix or the flame?"
"Which hurts more, Cruciatus or a sledgehammer?"
"All right, fine, go in. Bastard."
And I am trying to parse why Hermione is in Gryffindor
'Cause otherwise Harry would've been screwed?
That was another thing I loved, the password as question for Ravenclaw.
Totally! I would, without a doubt, be in Ravenclaw.
Or Hufflepuff.
Maybe there was another way into the Ravenclaw tower.
"Which came first the phoenix or the flame?"
"Which hurts more, Cruciatus or a sledgehammer?"
"All right, fine, go in. Bastard."
"Who would win in a fight: pirate or ninja?"
"Batman."
"Well done. You may enter. Nerd."