This thread is a focused discussion group. Please see the first post below for the current topic and upcoming book discussions. While natter will inevitably happen, we encourage you to treat this like a virtual book club and try to keep your posts in that spirit.
By consensus, this thread is reopened specifically to discuss Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It will be closed again once that discussion has run its course.
***SPOILER ALERT***
- **Spoilers for Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows lie here. Read at your own risk***
I noticed that too, and wondered whether "stripping" meant all the way. How could you show that in a kids' film?
They could be stripping off screen and you would just see the real Harry's reaction to them. Easily done.
My favorite callback begins in book 5.
Ohhhh, nice.
Now I'm going to have to do a full reread to catch all the threads. When I'm done with school. The break I took to read this has already put me behind in my current class, darn it.
"And what the ruddy hell are dementors?"
Cool. Thanks for digging that up, Aimée.
At the end of OoTP, my very first thought was...what a waste of a perfectly good magical mirror. How could she possibly have introduced such a cool thing and then left it there. It's going to get broken in the bottom of that trunk, ya know. Blahblahrantycakes.
Memo
Fr: JK
To: Beej
Re: Whinging about things of which you know not
Comment:
Shut up and read.
I loved all the fucking callbacks. The closet under the stairs!
I know!
If pressed, I would have remembered the closet and the spiders and the events that led to Harry getting his own room, but so much has happened that it just slipped my mind.
His 'it's so small' reaction to the space is exactly what crossed my mind when I remembered quarters being much bigger than they are.
Sniff. Our little boy is all grown up. And scarred...in so many ways. And wise...and brave and well...
Thanks JK for this great gift.
And you too JRR and PJ.
And...to a lesser degree cuz I'm still miffed with him...George.
I'm so grateful for all the fun my mind has had in this lifetime.
My favorite callback begins in book 5.
The first time I read book 5, I hit that scene and knew, KNEW!, that Petunia was talking about Snape. That's the point where I became absolutely certain that Snape was not evil, and that he had renounced the Death Eaters because of his feelings for Lily.
(Makes "Snape+Lily!!" handwavey gestures at Fay)
Ha ha ha ha ha
My sentiments exactly!
In other news, the French title for this volume is really much less subtle:
Harry Potter et les reliques de la mort
With re: to Lily/Snape.
Where did Lily and Petunia and Snape grow up? Is Spinner's End close to Privet Drive, or is it another part of England altogether?
It would be neat if Lily and Petunia turned up to have grown up in a moderately magical town and that fueled Petunia's dislike even more.
I think it's neat that there's so much unknown about all these things. JK has a quote saying fanfic is like people moving furniture around in her house. She doesn't mind that it's out there, she just doesn't want to see what people are doing.